Love and all the associated emotions has played a part in many murders since the beginning of time. This basic human emotion is perhaps most responsible for terrible acts committed in its name.
It is perhaps not surprising that this played a part in Fred’s trial. Most of the evidence was heard during the court sessions on the 19 March and 19 April, 2007.
The court heard that Inge had had many suitors during her first year at university – including the best friend of Fred van der Vyver. Wimpie Boshoff, Inge’s best friend, was called to the stand to shed light on whether Marius Botha was still secretly in love with her. (He was the guy she had lunch with on the day of the murder).
Marius Botha
Inge had studied with both Marius and Fred from 2001 to 2004. In 2005 Marius became Fred’s flatmate. (He is the guy who helped Fred deliver the kitchen cupboard)
Wimpie stated that back in 2001, Marius had been in love with Inge. At the time he had written her love letters and poems. One letter was possible one meter long, including a poem. This however was not confirmed by Wimpie. He just said “I’m not sure. I know it was a long letter with a poem.”
“Inge told me Marius said to her that their friendship would never be the same again after she started dating Fred,” Boshoff said.
Dup de Bruyn, the defence advocate asked Wimpie whether Marius was still secretly in love with Inge at the time of her murder in 2005. He replied that Marius “definitely hadn’t been in love with her since 2002″,Gucci Handbags; and that they had become friends instead.
Jean Minnaar
Jean had also been a classmate of Inge and in 2005 had lived in the same complex as Fred and Marius. It emerged that he too had been in love with Inge during their first year of university.
“She was a very beautiful girl. In 2001 Botha, Minnaar and many others were in love with Inge,” Boshoff said to amused laughter in court.
(Jean was the guy who asked Fred to buy the kitchen cupboard on the morning of the murder and to deliver it to him the same evening).
Fred’s Relationship
Wimpie mentioned in court that he thought that Inge and Fred had a “perfect relationship”. He also mentioned that Inge had confided in him that she was planning to get engaged to Fred in 2006.
However, while on the stand, he said that he did not tell a private investigator that Inge had confided that she had had a “hell of a fight” with Fred
Evidence of this fight was supported by the letter that Inge had given to Fred on the morning of the murder.
He had gone into more detail of the fight in his testimony a month earlier.
According to Wimpie, he and Inge had had lunch on the day of her murder. He said that at the lunch, Inge had told him that she thought that the relationship with Fred was over. He laughed it off,Replica Burberry, “But she said they had a hell of a fight that morning and that he had then left.
“I told her she mustn’t fight with Fred because I thought they were well-suited. She said that during the fight Fred had told her that she had to think about whether she wanted the relationship.
“Inge said she had taken a letter to him at the university (of Stellenbosch) where he was attending a lecture. She said that when Fred took the letter he said he would think about it. That was the last time I saw her,” Boshoff said.
Apparently, the cause of the fight was because Fred had found out that Inge had given Marius a kiss. This was found in a message on Fred’s computer sent by Inge. She did go on to say that the kiss was innocent and that there was no need for him to be jealous.
Observations and Comments:
1) It seems that there was trouble in paradise. As mentioned earlier, love is a very important factor in many murders due to the intensity of the emotions involved. Was this the case with Fred? Was he angry enough to kill her? I guess it is possible, but when you read the text messages, it seems that he wasn’t particularly angry.
2) Where was Wimpie Boshoff at the time of the murder? I am sure there was an investigation into his alibi, but it would have been really interesting to hear it! By his own admission he was her best friend. Could he have been in love with her himself? Could he have been jealous about her relationship with Fred?
3) Marius Botha had clearly been infatuated with Inge. After all,Mulberry Handbags, he wrote her the long (one meter???) letter with poem back in 2001. Maybe he did in fact keep his feelings secret – after all you wouldn’t want your best friend and room mate finding out you were in love with his girl! This premise of mine is reinforced when considering that he had recently been kissed by Inge. This was supposedly the cause of the fight!
I wonder what his alibi is? Again, I am sure the police had investigated this avenue. I am just curious.
4) Jean Minnaar – same as for Marius. Was he also secretly in love still?
5) It seems as though there was a lot of interest in Inge. After all, she was a beautiful girl! But could this open up the possibility of other suspects? It seems as though there could be a number of people with ‘love’,replica handbag; as a motive.
6) One thing does confuse me. If Fred was so angry at Inge about the supposed kiss with Marius, why does he meet with Marius later to move the cupboard to Jean’s house? Surely he would have been just as angry – or more so – that his flatmate and friend had been kissing/stealing his girlfriend? Neither Marius or Fred have mentioned that they had an kind of argument or fight.
To me this doesn’t sound like a guy who was overly angry and emotional. But then again maybe he had just bottled it up inside. The thing is, when dealing with emotions, it is really hard to tell! Just in this case we can see how suspicion can easily be cast on nearly every player!